Reinstatement lawsuit: conditions and time limits
· 4 min read

Termination of an employment contract by the employer does not in every case mean that the employee can request reinstatement. The Labour Law makes this protection, known as "job security" (iş güvencesi), subject to certain conditions and limits it with rather short time limits. This article summarises the conditions of a reinstatement lawsuit (işe iade davası) and the time limits to watch, within the framework of Labour Law No. 4857 and Labour Courts Law No. 7036.
Who benefits from job security?
To file a reinstatement lawsuit, the following conditions must be met together (Law No. 4857, Art. 18):
- Thirty or more employees: At least thirty employees must work at the workplace. If the employer has more than one workplace in the same line of business, this number is determined on the basis of the total number of employees in all of those workplaces.
- At least six months' seniority: The employee's periods of work in one or different workplaces of the same employer are counted together.
- Indefinite-term contract: Those employed under a fixed-term employment contract are as a rule outside this protection.
- Not being an employer's representative: Employer's representatives and their deputies who manage the entire business, and employer's representatives who manage the entire workplace and have the authority to hire and dismiss employees, cannot benefit from job security.
Valid reason and written notice of termination
An employer who terminates the contract of an employee covered by job security must base the termination on a valid reason. A valid reason may arise from the employee's competence or conduct, or from the operational requirements of the enterprise, the workplace or the work (Law No. 4857, Art. 18). By contrast, reasons such as trade union membership, having recourse to legal remedies against the employer, race, sex, religion, political opinion, pregnancy or childbirth do not constitute a valid reason.
Notice of termination must be given in writing, and the reason for termination must be stated clearly and precisely (Law No. 4857, Art. 19). If the termination is to be made for reasons related to the employee's conduct or performance, the employee's defence against the allegations must as a rule be obtained first. The burden of proving that the termination is based on a valid reason lies with the employer; if the employee claims that the termination was based on a different reason, he or she must prove that claim (Law No. 4857, Art. 20).
Mediator first, then lawsuit
A lawsuit for reinstatement cannot be filed directly. It is mandatory to apply to a mediator within one month of service of the notice of termination (Law No. 4857, Art. 20; Law No. 7036, Art. 3). A lawsuit filed without first applying to a mediator is dismissed on procedural grounds for lack of a precondition for bringing the case.
If no agreement is reached in mediation, a lawsuit must be filed in the labour court (iş mahkemesi) within two weeks of the date on which the final report is drawn up. If the parties agree, the dispute may also be referred to a private arbitrator within the same period. These time limits are peremptory (hak düşürücü); if they are missed, the reinstatement claim can no longer be asserted. It is therefore important to note the date of service of the notice of termination and the date of the final report.
If the court finds the termination invalid
A judgment that the termination is invalid does not mean that the employee automatically returns to work; here too the law prescribes certain steps (Law No. 4857, Art. 21):
- The employee must apply to the employer to return to work within ten working days of service of the final judgment. If the employee does not apply within this period, the termination produces the effects of a valid termination and the employer is liable only for the legal consequences of such a termination.
- If the application is made in time, the employer must reinstate the employee within one month.
The main monetary rights that arise in this process are as follows:
- Compensation for non-reinstatement (işe başlatmama tazminatı): If the employer does not reinstate the employee, it pays the employee compensation of at least four and at most eight months' wages. The amount of this compensation is determined in the judgment on the invalidity of the termination.
- Wages for the idle period (boşta geçen süre ücreti): For the period during which the employee was not employed until the judgment becomes final, the employee is paid wages and other entitlements accrued for up to four months.
- Set-off: If the employee is reinstated, wages and other entitlements previously paid in advance, as well as pay for the notice period and severance pay, are deducted from this payment.
These provisions cannot be altered by contract; contractual provisions to the contrary are void (Law No. 4857, Art. 21).
A brief assessment
In a reinstatement lawsuit, the outcome often depends on whether the time limits were observed and on the content of the documents produced during the termination process. The notice of termination, any letter requesting the employee's defence, the employment contract, payslips and information on the number of employees at the workplace are the key elements of the assessment. On the employer's side, too, setting out the reason for termination correctly from the outset is decisive for any disputes that may arise later. It is advisable to obtain a lawyer's opinion on your specific situation.
This article is for general information only and does not constitute legal advice. Legislation and case law may change; please check the current position.


